$6,000 for a motel room!?

Ten Reasons Why Disney's Star Wars Hotel Was A Spectacular Failure

Ten Reasons Why Disney's Star Wars Hotel Was A Spectacular Failure
Jenny Nicholson went viral for sharing her nightmare experience staying at the Star Wars: Galactic Starcruiser resort. Here's a breakdown.
· 12.7k reads ·
· ·

Social media influencer Jenny Nicholson's four-hour long video of her nightmare vacation experience staying at Walt Disney World's Star Wars: Galactic Starcruiser, before it closed down, has garnered over three million views in its first three days.

Nicholson said she paid for the vacation herself, and that the issues began the moment she tried booking a room. Here is a breakdown of what Nicholson encountered, and why she's calling it a nightmare.

The rooms were on a 'IYKYK' basis

Nicholson said that the hotel management gave her the run around when she called to make a reservation. When she booked her room โ€” for roughly $6,000 โ€” she assumed that all of the rooms were equal, especially since no upgrades were mentioned. However, she learned that many of the elusive premium accommodations were already booked on an informal if you know, you know basis, and she had missed out.

Screenshot-2024-05-22-174216

Not paying extra meant things, kind of, got worse

Among one of the premium experiences was a seat at the "captains table." However, since Nicholson did not buy this, she was later seated behind a pillar during the entire dinner show, obstructing her view completely.

Screenshot-2024-05-22-173910

Space travel is not more efficient than TSA

Guests were greeted with an outdoor waiting area at the hotel and while it was hot, they also had to wait for a "special elevator" meant to replicate space travel. While it was a cool visual effect, waiting for it reportedly took very long, especially with everyone's luggage involved.

Screenshot-2024-05-22-174803

Too big to fit in space? Oh well...

While the rooms were designed in order to be shared, Nicholson believed that Disney overestimated just how small the rooms actually were. She said that maybe five adults could squeeze in together to help save money, but it would be a rather uncomfortable experience over the course of a two-night stay.

Screenshot-2024-05-22-134829

It wasn't based on any fan favorite locations

Despite Star Wars having a list of popular locations, Disney decided to take a different approach for the resort. Guests were aboard a ship that was so old, it was said to exist through "the entire franchise." While Disney's intention was to make set design changes easier, had the resort stayed open longer, remodeling things set in different Star Wars eras would've been a bigger hit with fans. Another downside was the conflicting reality of a "luxury" Star Wars hotel and no indication of the rebellion, or its causes.

Screenshot-2024-05-22-175850

Not all actors are created equal

While trying to immerse herself in the experience, Nicholson said she was able to pick up on one major flaw. Looking at their ear pieces, she said she believes the actors were being fed information about the guests, and when she used a fake name during the experience, the actors weren't too pleased.

Screenshot-2024-05-22-180326

The app was pointless

Nicholson said that despite tracking her app activity diligently, she did not see any difference in her experience. The app was supposed to allow guests to text with AI versions of the hotel's many Star Wars characters and give visitors a customizable experience. However, not only did her data never show up, it didn't give her an accurate experience either.

Screenshot-2024-05-22-135110

There are no vegetarians in the galaxy, apparently

While Nicholson spoke highly of the abundance of food in the hotel, the same could not be said regarding the resorts vegetarian options. As part of the experience, guests food costs were included in the total price of the package. However, while the hotel promised that their chefs could make custom meal options, their offerings for vegetarians ended up being a plate of steamed cauliflower.

Screenshot-2024-05-22-180104

Dressing up was frowned upon

As odd as it sounds, dressing up only got Nicholson strange looks by a lot of folks, including some resort staff too. The resort was advertised as a complete role-playing experience, but choosing your own character was not really embraced by the actors. In her opinion, it appeared the hotel seemed apprehensive at the idea of catering to the vast majority of main characters.

Screenshot-2024-05-22-174652

Do not exit through the gift shop, there are just cobwebs

You'd think Disney would be taking the resort gift shops as a chance to grab more money. Upon visiting them, only empty shelves could be found instead. Indeed, all of the exclusive merchandise promised to guests was often out of stock and never restocked, according to Nicholson.

Screenshot-2024-05-22-175233

Customer service was worse than the empire and rebellion combined

Nicholson shared that not only did Disney lose her merchandise, they also did not take any photos of her despite her having purchased a photo pass. With no photos of her trip, even her request for a refund and merchandise replacement were ignored by Disney โ€” until she posted about it online, and they realized she was an influencer. She also noted that other guests faced similar issues.

Screenshot-2024-05-23-092833

The final conclusion

Nicholson closed by saying that many of the hotel's features were once meant to be part of the actual theme park. Pointing to several examples, including the hotel's theater dining experience, she said these last-minute changes appear to be a part of Disney's latest trend in moving it's best features behind a paywall. As for the empty hotel now, she believes it will most likely either be used for corporate meetings, storage or ironically enough, an expensive add-on dining experience for park guests.

Watch Nicholson's complete video:


Via Jenny Nicholson.

Comments

  1. Rick Hunt 16 hours ago

    "Jenny Nicholson" created a four-hour click-bait YouTube video full of misinformation and slanted opinion to trash a first-of-its-kind immersive experience that was given positive reviews by an overwhelming number of paying guests. Why? To make money.

    To debunk:
    The different cabin types and prices were clearly advertised on the Walt Disney World website, as were the upgraded experiences such as sitting at the Captain's Table. Why was she so ill-informed before making a reservation for such an expensive vacation?

    As for getting seated "behind a pole," the performers moved about the entire dining room throughout each performance. It would be impossible not to see what was happening, and her point is an exaggeration.

    Addressing the queue at the arrival doors, guests were repeatedly warned about showing up early and were clearly given a three-hour window to board before the experience began.

    The story did not focus solely on Rey/Kylo/First Order and contained appearances by canon characters including Yoda and Chewbacca, as well as references to Han, Lea, the Hutts, etc. Again, a slanted argument without merit.

    The app worked great and moved the story along for me and my two companions, who all chose different allegiances and paths. We all attained special achievements and awards just as if we were doing missions in an RPG online. There were no "weird looks" from cast members in the Starcruiser or Galaxy's Edge when we dressed up in costume, in fact when we were in the park the cast members played along with us and other park guests complimented our costumes and asked to take selfies with us.

    The gift shop was completely stocked and if I wanted to spend thousands more on merch it was readily available. As it was, we bought a special edition lightsaber and a droid, just like if we were in the theme park, wow!

    The staff were professional, courteous, outstanding in the roles, and the very definition of Disney cast members going above and beyond their duties to ensure a great experience for all. The food was great tasting, the rooms were comfortable and the entire experience was so immersive it made me shed a few tears at the finale.

    This video presentation is just rage baiting people who could not afford the high admission price. I assure you that if it was at the All-Star Resorts price point you would have heard nothing but rave reviews for the experience. Being the first to develop an all-new entertainment experience comes with a steep learning curve and Disney did make mistakes with marketing and price, but I assure you that the actual time aboard the Galactic Starcruiser was joyful and wondrous, just like everything else that makes Walt Disney World great for kids and adults alike. This is not the last you will see of immersive entertainment, and when Universal opens 'The Harry Potter Hotel" you'll be burning with FOMO.

  2. Unknown 18 hours ago

    Yeah, this video is just click bait. The a available room types were all clearly advertised in the website.
    All the staff were super helpful and accommodating, there are maybe 4 seats with a poor view of the stage. However all the performers move through out the dining hall constantly so everyone got a view of what was going on.
    There was a small queue to get in but the staff brought water and snacks out and engaged in banter. They specifically tell everyone not to turn up early with clear boarding times shown. If you didn't want to wait you could have arrived an hour later and not missed out on anything.
    There was lots of in universe references through out the ship and these were highlighted by a lot of the staff. It really did feel like being on a star wars ship. If you want to pilot a ship from the movies they have that ride in galaxies edge.
    All the actors did a great job. Doing improvisation with over a hundred people is not an easy thing. Lots of people on my trip all used in universe names and the cast had not problems or issue with it at all. Sandro and Raif both had amazing interactions with my son and made the trip really special.
    The app worked great for our group and did provide this interactions and interactivity with the ship. Some people did have technical issues but they were solved quickly by the crew.
    We informed the staff ahead of time about our dietary issues and they made excellent food for us and others that was appropriate. In fact the food was a highlight of the trip and some of the best I've had at Disney.
    Yeah about 75% of our trip was dressed up, no strange looks and lots of compliments from cast and other passengers.
    When we went the gift shop stayed pretty well stocked. Since her trip was close to the end then yes by then Disney was not making more items to keep it full so some things were not available anymore.
    I saw lots of people doing photo sessions through the trip and everyone was super happy with them. The staff were amazing and truly friendly and helpful during the entire trip not at all the same experience for us.
    Was everything perfect, no. I wish it had been an extra day longer. A few of the dishes were a tad salty for my taste. It was super expensive. Would I do it again if it came back, I would in a heartbeat. It was a truly amazing experience and fulfilled a lot of my childhood dreams. It was marketed badly, it was not a star wars hotel but the actual execution and especially the staff and cast were truly amazing.


Cut Through The Chaos With Digg Edition

Sign up for Digg's daily morning newsletter to get the most interesting stories. Sent every morning.